Churches and Chapels
Sacred Spaces That Welcome Your Love Story
If you’re dreaming of a ceremony with the beauty and reverence of a church — but still want it to reflect your unique relationship, beliefs, and traditions — you’re not alone. More and more couples are seeking sacred spaces that feel meaningful without requiring membership or adherence to specific religious practices.
The churches and chapels listed here are places that have been known for being open, welcoming, and affirming to all. Whether your ceremony is interfaith, spiritual-but-not-religious, or simply personal and heartfelt, these venues offer a beautiful blend of tradition and flexibility.
From stained-glass windows to peaceful sanctuaries, these spaces invite you to bring your love, your vows, and your people — just as you are.
Please note: We do not represent these venues. We advertise them here on our website for people looking for a church to rent for small ceremonies. You must contact them directly.
Bating Hollow Congregational Church
This church is now one of Georgio’s house vendors. It’s a great little building that comes with or without a minister. I have found “Congregational” Churches more willing to rent space to couples as they are self supporting.
CW Post Interfaith Chapel
The Chapel at Long Island University, CW Post is stunningly beautiful and the staff there is eager to help you book your wedding date. All of the photos that come out of there are fantastic!
Historical Chapel – Woodbury
This is a lovely old building with a tin ceiling, stained glass windows and oak pews. It comes with an officiant and organist if needed, but you can bring your own too.
Huntington Unitarian Universalist Fellowship
This looks like a castle from the outside but inside is modern. There are UUF’s all over Long Island and, to the best of my knowledge, all will rent space.
Islip Grange – Sayville
Please note: We do not represent this venue. We advertise it here on our website for people looking for a church to rent for small ceremonies. You must contact them directly. Booking is done through the Cultural Affairs Office of the Islip Department of Parks and Recreation.
This historic scale model of an 1867 Dutch Reform Church, originally located in West Sayville, is simple, quaint and available to rent for ceremonies and meetings. With 12 pew benches, the church accommodates approximately 60 people. Food and drink are not permitted inside the church.
Fees (as of Jan 2026):
RESIDENT: $360 for 3 hour minimum/$120 each additional hour
NON-RESIDENT: $600 for 3 hour minimum/$200 each additional hour
$200 Security (refundable after final inspection of facility)
$150 Sunday/Holiday feeContact the Islip Cultural Affairs Office: (631) 224-5430 | CULTURALAFFAIRS@ISLIPNY.GOV
Mill Neck Manor Chapel
Mill Neck Manor, located on the prestigious North Shore of Long Island, is a majestic Tudor Revival mansion set on an 86-acre scenic estate overlooking the Long Island Sound. The mansion, once called Sefton Manor, was owned by Robert Leftwich Dodge and his wife, the cosmetics heiress Lillian Sefton Dodge. The chapel within, dedicated in the 1950s is open to the community for weddings and special events. Call 516-628-4239 or visit millneckmanorhouse.org.
Old Whaler’s Church – Sag Harbor
What a great old church! 44 Union Street, Sag Harbor. It holds 600 guests, the fee is reasonable, and if you were not thinking of a big reception they have a room downstairs that can also be rented.
Scarsdale Community Baptist Church – Westchester
An absolutely beautiful church. Wooden pews, stained glass windows, oriental rug runner, are just some of the attributes of this location. If a “church” is what you are looking for in Westchester this one is well worth a look see.
St. Johnland Chapel – Kings Park
St. Johnland Chapel sits on the property of St. Johnland Rehabilitation Center – This is a Great Church Building in a park like setting. If you are having a problem finding a location and you want a church – go see this venue. They don’t host too many weddings and it is sometimes hard to find someone for information but it IS worth the effort.
The Old Grace Church – Massapequa
For couples dreaming of an intimate wedding ceremony filled with history and character, Old Grace Church in Massapequa offers a truly special setting.
Built in 1844 and part of the historic Grace Church Complex, this beautifully preserved Long Island landmark provides the warmth and charm of a traditional church wedding while welcoming couples from all backgrounds and traditions. Recently recognized as a Best Ceremony Location, Old Grace Church offers a picturesque and meaningful space for couples seeking a ceremony venue with a story all its own.
Long Island Wedding Officiants is proud to work with Old Grace Church and to provide officiants for couples choosing to celebrate their marriage in this unique historic setting. Whether your ceremony is spiritual, secular, interfaith, traditional, or completely personalized, our officiants will work with you to create a ceremony that feels authentically yours.
Located in the heart of Massapequa, Old Grace Church is a wonderful choice for couples who love the beauty and intimacy of a classic church wedding without the requirement of belonging to a particular congregation or denomination.
Photo: OrionBlue / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0
https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Category%3AOld_Grace_Church_Complex_%28Massapequa%2C_New_York%29
Unitarian Universalist Congregation at Shelter Rock – Manhasset
UU’s are always warm and welcoming to all faiths and genders so if you’re looking for something “church” like without the dogma these may be the folks you want to meet! UUs also have a great Religious Education program for children.
Unity Church of Healing Light – Huntington Station
Located in Huntington Station, it holds 140, comes with or without clergy, they boast an organ, bride’s dressing room, ample parking, “extremely beautiful space at an affordable price.
